Foster care nightmare: abuse allegations rock trump-era immigration policy
Five months. That’s how long a young legal permanent resident waited for his three-year-old daughter’s release from federal custody after she crossed the US-Mexico border with her mother. But the reunion he desperately sought brought a far more devastating revelation: allegations of sexual abuse at the foster home where she’d been placed—a direct consequence, he believes, of the Trump administration’s accelerated detention policies.
The price of expedited deportation
The case, now unfolding in federal court, exposes a chilling side effect of the former president’s 2025 immigration reforms, which dramatically increased detention times for immigrant children and families. What began as a routine border crossing near El Paso on September 16th quickly spiraled into a protracted ordeal. After the mother was charged with making false statements and separated from her daughter, the toddler was placed in the care of the Office of Refugee Resettlement (ORR).
The father’s efforts to secure his daughter’s release were repeatedly stalled. He was told, repeatedly, that scheduling a fingerprinting appointment was impossible. During this limbo, his daughter disclosed to a caregiver that an older child staying at the Harlingen, Texas foster home had sexually abused her multiple times, resulting in visible injuries. A caregiver noted the child's underwear was on backward, raising immediate alarm.
Federal officials offered a terse explanation—an “accident”—and assured the father his daughter would be examined, but refused to provide any further information, citing an ongoing investigation. “I asked them, ‘What happened?’” the father told the Associated Press, his voice thick with frustration. “I’m her father. I want to know what’s going on.’ And they just told me they couldn’t give me more information.”

A system under strain
While the girl underwent a forensic exam and interview—the results of which remain undisclosed to her father—the older child accused of the abuse was removed from the foster program. Lauren Fisher Flores, the lawyer representing the child, argues the case underscores a systemic failure. “To have your child abused while in the government’s care, to not understand what has happened or how to protect them, to not even be told about the abuse, it is unimaginable,” she stated.
The surge in detention times reflects a deliberate shift in policy. When Donald Trump began his second term in 2025, the average custody time for children in ORR care hovered around 37 days. By February of this year, that figure had ballooned to nearly 200 days. Legal advocates, anticipating these consequences, began filing habeas petitions—emergency lawsuits—to expedite the release of children. The American Bar Association’s ProBar project, according to Fisher Flores, has handled eight such petitions this year alone, a previously unheard-of necessity.
The father’s eventual reunion with his daughter came only after attorneys filed a habeas petition. It was then, in the preparation of the lawsuit, that he learned the full extent of the trauma his daughter had endured.
The psychological toll on the child is evident. Now living with her grandparents in Chicago while her case moves through immigration court, she suffers from nightmares and is easily upset—a stark contrast to her previous demeanor. “She was never like that” before, her father lamented, a heartbreaking testament to the lasting impact of prolonged detention and alleged abuse.
Neha Desai, managing director at Children’s Human Rights and Dignity at the National Center for Youth Law, frames this case as “another version of Family separation,” echoing the controversies of earlier immigration policies. The legal battles continue, but one truth remains undeniable: for this young girl, the promise of safety and reunification came at a devastating cost. The clock is ticking.