politics

Ellison's '70%' audience claim faces reality check

David Ellison, the media mogul now steering CBS News and poised to take control of CNN, has built a narrative around capturing a mythical “center” American audience. But a key statistic underpinning that strategy—a claim that 70% of Americans identify as center-left to center-right—appears to be deeply flawed, according to publicly available polling data. This raises serious questions about the foundation of Ellison’s editorial vision and the direction of his newly acquired networks.

The disconnect between vision and data

During a recent CNBC appearance, Ellison repeatedly cited this 70% figure as a guiding principle for CBS News and, soon, CNN. The premise is simple: a vast, underserved middle ground exists in American Politics, hungry for news that isn't dominated by partisan extremes. It's a compelling argument, particularly given the increasingly polarized media landscape and aligns with the approach championed by Bari Weiss, a prominent figure Ellison has brought into his orbit.

However, the numbers don’t support it. A YouGov survey from last fall indicated that only 40% of U.S. adults consider themselves “center-left,” “center,” or “center-right.” Pew Research Center’s data from last year echoes this, putting the figure at 41%, and Gallup’s findings reveal a 45% share of Americans identifying as Republican-leaning or Democratic-leaning independents—a new high, suggesting a continued pull towards the poles.

When confronted with this discrepancy, a Paramount Skydance spokesperson insisted the company “stands by the stat,” but couldn’t provide a specific survey to validate Ellison’s assertion. This lack of transparency is concerning, especially when a core editorial strategy is built upon a shaky foundation. Ellison first touted the 70% figure in August, suggesting it would dictate the network's programming and commitment to a more neutral perspective. The acquisition of Weiss’s Free Press and its focus on appealing to a similar demographic further cemented this strategy.

A sizing-up battle for centrists

A sizing-up battle for centrists

Daniel Cassino, a professor of government and polling expert at Fairleigh Dickinson University, notes the inherent difficulty in categorizing Americans’ political leanings. “The audience for every news channel is largely going to consist of partisans,” he observed, “because they’re the ones who care about political news and follow it.” While a centrist-oriented news organization could potentially find success, it would face considerable headwinds.

The early results at CBS News haven't been encouraging. While 60 Minutes remains a powerhouse, the network’s morning show and flagship evening news program—with Tony Dokoupil at the helm—have struggled to gain traction. The CBS Evening News recently hit a new low in viewership, averaging just 4 million total viewers in March. This casts further doubt on the viability of Ellison's strategy and the ability of his networks to capture the elusive “70%” he envisions.

The departure of former CBS News correspondent Scott MacFarlane, who dismissed the notion of targeting a specific “purple” demographic, adds another layer of skepticism to Ellison’s approach. “There can’t be a plan for how to go: ‘We want to find that 10% of purple…people,’” MacFarlane stated bluntly.

Ultimately, Ellison's reliance on a demonstrably flawed statistic underscores a troubling trend in media leadership: prioritizing narrative over data. Until he can provide concrete evidence to support his claim, his vision for CBS News and CNN risks being built on a foundation of sand.