Minneapolis police chief blames surge complaints on ice operations
Minneapolis Police Chief Brian
O'Hara finds himself navigating a fresh wave of conduct complaints, a situation he directly links to the recent ICE surge operations. The accusations, totaling 30 since he took office, are casting a long shadow over his leadership, particularly as he seeks renomination by Mayor Jacob Frey.
A surge in scrutiny: complaints double
City data reveals a concerning trend: a doubling of complaints filed against O'Hara since September, coinciding with the federal immigration enforcement actions. While eight complaints have been dismissed by the Office of Community Safety, concluding no disciplinary action is warranted, a significant 22 remain open. The details, however, remain shrouded in secrecy, released only if punitive measures are deemed necessary—a policy that extends to the public, preventing transparency regarding who is lodging these claims and their specific nature.
O'Hara, who inherited a department still reeling from the aftermath of George Floyd's murder in 2020, has become a lightning rod for criticism from across the political spectrum. His handling of the ICE surge, in particular, appears to have fueled the recent influx of complaints. “Apparently since the surge, the number of complaints have doubled, which I think that says something about it right there,” he stated to WCCO, acknowledging he’s not privy to the specifics of the allegations.
Professor Rachel Moran, a police accountability expert at the University of St. Thomas School of Law, highlights the unusual volume of complaints. “Data shows that O’Hara’s predecessor, Medaria Arradondo, had just two complaints on file,” she noted. However, she cautions against drawing immediate conclusions, stating, “There’s simply no way of knowing, for the time being, if O'Hara is facing serious accusations. The complaints can be lodged by a fellow police officer or a member of the public from just about anywhere in the country.” The ease with which anyone, regardless of Minneapolis residency, can file a complaint underscores the unpredictability of these accusations—they could be based on genuine grievances or fueled by personal animosity.
Mayor Frey, in a statement, has voiced his support for O’Hara, praising his leadership through challenging crises and his efforts to rebuild the police department and foster trust with the community. He affirmed that the city takes all personnel complaints seriously and conducts investigations as appropriate. Frey’s statement, notably, stopped short of explicitly confirming his intention to renominate O’Hara, leaving the chief’s future uncertain as the August deadline approaches.
O’Hara, confident in the progress made during his tenure, expressed optimism about securing Frey’s nomination. “I think it’s very clear that there’s been results over the past three and a half years here,” he asserted. “There’s been significant change in the police department, it’s been positive.” The Minneapolis Police Officers Federation president, Lt. Sherral Schmidt, has yet to comment on the situation.
The escalating complaints and the opaque complaint process raise fundamental questions about accountability and transparency within the Minneapolis Police Department, underscoring the ongoing challenges in rebuilding public trust after a period of intense scrutiny.